Stop Telling Your Team It’ll Be Over by Christmas


people sitting on chair in front of table while holding pens during daytime

Seventy-three percent of workers don’t trust their leadership to be fully honest when a company hits financial trouble. That figure comes from a LiveCareer survey of 900 U.S. workers run in July 2026, and the companion number is worse: only 8% said their leadership is fully open and transparent. Most people reading that will assume the problem is executives hiding bad news. Some of it is. But a good share of the damage comes from something more ordinary and more forgivable: managers who tell their teams that things will be better soon, because they want it to be true.

I’ve done it. Most managers have. And the clearest explanation of why it backfires comes from a Navy pilot who spent nearly eight years as a prisoner of war.

What Stockdale told Jim Collins

James Stockdale was the highest-ranking U.S. military officer held in the “Hanoi Hilton” prison camp, captive from 1965 to 1973 and tortured more than twenty times. When Jim Collins interviewed him for Good to Great, he asked who didn’t make it out. Stockdale’s answer, as Collins recounts it:

“Oh, that’s easy. The optimists. Oh, they were the ones who said, ‘We’re going to be out by Christmas.’ And Christmas would come, and Christmas would go. Then they’d say, ‘We’re going to be out by Easter.’ And Easter would come, and Easter would go. And then Thanksgiving, and then it would be Christmas again. And they died of a broken heart.”

Then the part that matters for anyone running a team. “You must never confuse faith that you will prevail in the end,” Stockdale said (a faith, he added, “which you can never afford to lose”), “with the discipline to confront the most brutal facts of your current reality, whatever they might be.”

Collins named that duality the Stockdale Paradox and found it in every one of the companies his research team classed as good to great. Their leaders held two beliefs at the same time: we will come through this, and the current situation is exactly as bad as the data says. Most managers can do one or the other. The skill is doing both in the same conversation.

The Christmas sentences managers actually say

Nobody in an office says “we’ll be out by Christmas.” They say things that work the same way:

  • “Once the reorg settles, things will calm down.”
  • “The hiring freeze should lift next quarter.”
  • “This is just a busy stretch. It’ll ease off after launch.”
  • “Leadership knows we’re stretched. Relief is coming.”
  • “We’re nearly through the worst of the migration.”

Each one swaps a fact the team can plan around for a date the manager doesn’t control. Each one feels kind when you say it. And each one sets a clock running in your team’s head. When the quarter ends and the freeze is still on, they don’t just absorb the disappointment. They recalculate how much your next forecast is worth.

That’s the part optimistic managers miss. The bad news arrives either way. The only thing you get to decide is whether it arrives with your credibility attached or with your credibility spent.

Why the hopeful date hurts more than the bad news

Two lines of research explain what’s going on.

The first is about uncertainty. In 2016, a team at University College London ran an experiment in which 45 volunteers played a game where turning over the wrong rock could earn them a mild electric shock. The odds changed as the game went on. Stress peaked when the chance of a shock was around 50%, and it was lower when people knew for certain they’d be shocked. Sweat and pupil dilation tracked the uncertainty, not the pain. The full paper in Nature Communications is careful about how far that generalizes; it’s a lab task, not a layoff. But the direction matches everything I’ve seen in operations. A team told “cuts are coming in March, and here’s what we know” settles faster than a team told “it’ll probably be fine.”

A hopeful date doesn’t remove uncertainty. It postpones it, and then it arrives again on the date you named, with a little less trust in the room.

The second line of research is about effort. Gabriele Oettingen has spent decades studying the difference between expecting a good outcome and fantasizing about one. In a 2002 paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, she and Doris Mayer reported that positive expectations, judgments grounded in past experience, predicted more effort and better results. Positive fantasies, vivid daydreams of the good future, predicted the opposite. Graduates who fantasized most about landing a great job had fewer offers and lower salaries later. Her explanation is that the fantasy lets you enjoy the outcome in advance, which quietly drains the energy you’d otherwise put into getting it.

Put those together and the manager’s comforting forecast does two kinds of harm. It stretches the uncertainty out, and it invites the team to relax into a future that hasn’t been earned.

The year I promised a finish line

Running operations at a large telecom, I spent a long stretch leading a team through a platform consolidation that was supposed to take nine months. We were collapsing several legacy systems onto one, and my people were doing their normal support load plus the migration work. It was a lot.

About four months in, I started telling them we’d be through the heavy part by the end of the summer. I believed it. The project plan said so. I said it in team meetings and in one-on-ones, partly because a couple of my strongest people were visibly worn down and I wanted to give them something to hold onto.

Summer ended. We weren’t through. A vendor dependency slipped, and a data quality problem on one of the old platforms turned out to be much bigger than anyone had scoped. I moved the date to Christmas. You can see where this is going.

What I remember most isn’t the slipped dates. It’s the moment in a one-on-one when one of my senior engineers, someone I’d worked with for years, said, politely, “I’ve stopped listening to the dates. Just tell me what’s next.” She wasn’t angry. She’d simply done the math on my forecasting and discounted it to zero. That was worse than angry.

What fixed it wasn’t a better date. It was a different kind of message. I stopped giving end dates for the whole effort and started giving the team three things every two weeks: what we now knew that we didn’t know before, what the next checkpoint was and when, and what I was doing about the load. The project still ran long. But the team stopped bracing for each announcement, and the senior engineer started asking questions in meetings again, which was the signal I’d been missing.

Splitting the message in two

The practical move in the Stockdale Paradox is to separate what you say into two buckets and never let them leak into each other.

The faith bucket holds what the team can count on regardless of how the situation unfolds. That’s almost never an outcome or a date. It’s your behavior and the team’s capability: “We’ve handled hard migrations before and we’ll handle this one.” “You’ll hear about changes from me before you hear them in the hallway.” “I’m not going to let this team carry both workloads without pushing back on scope.”

The facts bucket holds the current situation, stated as plainly as you’d state it to your own boss. “The vendor slipped six weeks. That pushes cutover past year end. I don’t have a new date yet, and I won’t give you one until I do.”

The failure mode is putting a hoped-for outcome into the faith bucket. “We’ll be done by summer” sounds like faith, but it’s actually a fact claim, and it can be proven wrong. Faith statements should be ones that stay true no matter what the calendar does.

State the fact with its source and its age

“Things are tight” is a mood. “Finance told us Thursday that the headcount request is on hold until the Q1 review” is a fact. Saying where it came from and when tells your team how much weight to put on it, and it shows them you’re passing information along rather than managing their feelings.

Give the next checkpoint, not the finish line

When you can’t honestly name an end date, name the next point where you’ll know more. “The vendor gives us a revised schedule on the 28th. I’ll share it with you that afternoon, whatever it says.” That’s a promise you can keep, and every kept promise rebuilds a little of what the missed dates cost. It’s the same logic behind a premortem: you’re trading a confident prediction for a commitment to keep looking.

Pair the hope with the obstacle out loud

Oettingen’s practical answer to the fantasy problem is a technique she calls mental contrasting: picture the good outcome, then immediately picture the specific obstacle standing in the way, then plan around it. A 2021 meta-analysis of 21 studies and nearly 16,000 participants found a small to medium effect on goal attainment when it’s combined with if-then planning, and the authors flag possible publication bias, so don’t oversell it. But the shape of it works well in a team meeting: “Here’s where we’re headed. Here’s the thing most likely to stop us. Here’s what we’ll do if it shows up.”

Where managers overcorrect

Once managers absorb this, a few of them swing too far the other way. Three patterns to watch for.

Treating “brutal facts” as permission to be brutal. Collins meant brutal as in unvarnished, not as in harsh delivery. You can give your team a hard number in a calm voice. The facts are meant to be brutal; you aren’t.

Sharing every rumor in the name of transparency. A fact has a source. Hallway speculation about the next round of cuts isn’t a fact, and passing it along spikes exactly the uncertainty the UCL work points to. If you don’t know, say you don’t know and say when you expect to.

Dropping the faith half entirely. A manager who only delivers bad news, with no statement of what the team can rely on, isn’t practicing the Stockdale Paradox. They’re practicing half of it, and teams in that state tend to start updating their résumés. Stockdale’s faith was unwavering. The point was never to give it up; it was to stop pinning it to a date.

Before your next team update

Read through what you’re planning to say and check three things.

Does any sentence contain a date or outcome you don’t control? If so, either cut it or attach the source and the uncertainty to it.

Is there at least one statement your team can count on no matter how the situation plays out? If not, add one, and make it about what you will do.

Did you give them the next checkpoint? If they leave the meeting knowing when they’ll hear more, you’ve removed more uncertainty than any optimistic forecast could.

The managers I’ve trusted most over the years were rarely the cheerful ones. They were the ones whose bad news always turned out to be accurate, which meant that when they did say things were going to be fine, people believed them. That trust is built in the hard months, not the easy ones. If you’re leading through one of those stretches now, the broader playbook for leading through change is worth a reread, but start with the next thing you say to your team, and leave Christmas out of it.

Ty Sutherland

Ty Sutherland is an operations and technology leader with 20+ years of experience. He is Director of IT Operations at SaskTel, founder of Ops Harmony (fractional COO and EOS Integrator), and former COO at WTFast. He writes Management Skills Daily to share practical management frameworks that work in the real world.

Recent Posts